Sen. Josh Harkins, R-Flowood

Less than 24 hours after officials revealed a state agency leader allegedly allowed subcontractors to steal millions intended for poor Mississippians, lawmakers advanced legislation to heighten scrutiny of public assistance applicants. 

The bill, authored by Sen. Josh Harkins, R-Flowood, would give the State Auditor’s office new authority to examine income tax returns to determine eligibility for public assistance programs such as Medicaid, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families or Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program.

The Senate Finance Committee passed the bill Thursday at the request of state Auditor Shad White, whose office investigated the case and arrested six people on embezzlement and fraud charges. The bill was originally filed in January.

Sen. John Horhn, D-Hinds

“This is not about compliance. This is about terror. We’re going to use this law and we’re going to terrorize a bunch of folks,” Sen. John Horhn, D-Jackson, said during the Thursday committee meeting. “What the history of our Medicaid compliance tells us is that it ain’t the recipients. It’s not the recipients, it’s providers. And in recent cases, it’s employees of the state of Mississippi.”

Earlier in the week, agents from the auditor’s office arrested former Human Services director John Davis and prominent education contractor Nancy New as part of the largest public embezzlement case in state history. Those involved allegedly stole more than $4.15 million from the federal TANF program.

When it comes to accountability in public assistance programs, state lawmakers have long focused on recipients. In recent years, this has included imposing drug testing and work requirements, as well as purchasing a new computer system to track and verify applicant information.

White, appointed by former Gov. Phil Bryant in 2018 and elected in 2019, promises a consistent approach to rooting out fraud “no matter where it is,” he told Mississippi Today Friday.

White requested the legislation to comply with a new federal requirement that his office redetermine the eligibility of able-bodied Medicaid recipients — a small portion of the program — within its annual audit.

To do this, White said he and other state auditors have determined they must gain “access to state income tax returns to make sure people are telling the truth when they tell Medicaid how much money they make.”

The audit would focus on about 60,700 able-bodied adult caretakers, who make up less than ten percent of a Medicaid program that serves mostly children. White said his office would examine a sample of those cases to determine if the program is serving people who do not qualify at any magnitude.

Harkins told Mississippi Today his intention is that only a select group from the auditor’s office would have the capability to pull the returns during a limited time period.

State Sen. Chris McDaniel, R-Ellisville

“If there’s one part of our budget that seems to expand every year, and eats away at all parts of our pocketbooks, it’s the Medicaid budget,” Sen. Chris McDaniel, R-Ellisville, said during the meeting, adding that the state must “make sure the people who are receiving it are those who deserve it and should be receiving it. And those that are not, well they shouldn’t be getting it.”

In 2018, White’s office conducted an audit of the Medicaid managed care companies and found improper payments totaling approximately $615,000, a very small fraction of the billions spent on the program.

Matt Westerfield, a spokesman for Medicaid, said the agency welcomes support from the state auditor to verify that people receiving Medicaid meet all eligibility criteria “to ensure resources remain available for those who qualify.”

Neighboring Louisiana senators rejected a similar proposal in 2019, Shreveport Times reported.

White also wants authority to examine income tax returns for recipients of other programs — such as TANF, the federal program at the center of the massive fraud scheme he uncovered — in the event the federal government requires that kind of audit in the future.

In July, his office released an annual audit outlining major issues with the human services department’s monitoring of millions in federal public assistance dollars, including a failure to maintain a full list of subgrantees.

“You can’t monitor who you don’t know you gave money to,” Stephanie Palmertree, financial and compliance audit director for the state auditor’s office, said at the time.

The state already has the laws it needs to prevent government officials from defrauding federal programs, White said. “We need to make sure people are complying with the laws.”

White said Senate leaders expressed interest in conducting a forensic audit of TANF spending, which would essentially trace the flow of every program dollar to subgrantees. The process would be intensive and White believes he would need to hire a private firm to conduct the work.

Gov. Phil Bryant announced on Friday he would appoint Shad White as the state’s next state auditor.

“That might be the only way to get to how all the money was spent and all the problems that were associated with it,” White said. “It will be expensive if we want to get it done in a timely way, but at this point, the expense is probably worth it.”

In 2018, the state established the Office of the Inspector General to identify fraud at the human services department. In the last year, the office identified 27 intentional TANF violations totaling $14,224, about one-hundredth of one percent of the program.

The auditor has not released a dollar amount of the embezzlement scheme as the investigation continues, but he said his office has identified at least $4.15 million stolen. If that money had been used for direct cash assistance to poor families, it could have funded more than 24,000 payments — a maximum of $170 a month for a family of three — serving over 2,000 families for the year.

For a family to qualify for TANF cash assistance, there must be a child living in the home and an adult must meet work requirements while also earning less than $680 a month for a family of three.

Other services offered by TANF, such as through New’s nonprofit Mississippi Community Education Center, which ran Families First for Mississippi, did not require a person to prove their eligibility.

Kayleigh Skinner contributed to this report.


We want to hear from you!

Central to our mission at Mississippi Today is inspiring civic engagement. We think critically about how we can foster healthy dialogue between people who think differently about government and politics. We believe that conversation — raw, earnest talking and listening to better understand each other — is vital to the future of Mississippi. We encourage you to engage with us and each other on our social media accounts, email our reporters directly or leave a comment for our editor by clicking the button below.


Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Anna Wolfe, a native of Tacoma, Wa., is an investigative reporter writing about poverty and economic justice. Before joining the staff at Mississippi Today in September of 2018, Anna worked for three years at Clarion Ledger, Mississippi’s statewide daily newspaper. She also worked as an investigative reporter for the Center for Public Integrity and Jackson Free Press, the capital city’s alternative newsweekly. Anna has received national recognition for her work, including the 2021 Goldsmith Prize for Investigative Reporting, the 2021 Collier Prize for State Government Accountability, the 2021 John Jay/Harry Frank Guggenheim Excellence in Criminal Justice Reporting Award, the 2020 Al Neuharth Innovation in Investigative Journalism Award and the February 2020 Sidney Award for reporting on Mississippi’s debtors prisons. She received the National Press Foundation’s 2020 Poverty and Inequality Award. She also received first place in the regional Green Eyeshade Awards in 2021 for Public Service in Online Journalism and 2020 for Business Reporting, and the local Bill Minor Prize for Investigative Journalism in 2019 and 2018 for reporting on unfair medical billing practices and hunger in the Mississippi Delta.