Roundtable gives insight to Cleveland students’ feelings

Print More

Aallyah Wright, Mississippi Today

Conversation participants (left to right) Ja’Darrius Carmichael, Jakiya Watson, Emma Hardy, Madeline McLaughlin, J’Terrica Trotter and Jakobe Richards and host Charles Coleman (kneeling) pose outside of Delta Arts Alliance.

 

CLEVELAND – Six students from the last graduating classes from Cleveland High School and East Side High School expressed their thoughts and feelings about their town, school experiences, and the upcoming school consolidation in a roundtable discussion here recently.

The conversation was convened as part of the Cleveland  Yearbook, a community news project by the Delta Arts Alliance and Reveal from the Center for Investigative Reporting, that seeks to create a snapshot of Cleveland through the eyes of its people.

Cheryl Devall, Senior Radio Editor for Reveal, teamed up with Charles Coleman, Project Manager for the Cleveland Yearbook, to have dialogue with a small group of students on Skype about what is going on in their town from their point of view.

Coleman selected three students from East Side – Jakiya Watson, Jakobe Richards, and J’Terrica  Trotter – and three students from Cleveland High – Madeline McLaughlin, Emma Hardy, and Ja’Darrius Carmichael – to engage in an hour-long conversation.

Mississippi Today was invited to observe and report on the exchange of views from the students. Here is an edited transcript of a portion of the discussion in which the students discussed some aspects of life in the public schools in Cleveland. Students are identified by their last name with an (E) for East Side High School or a (C) for Cleveland High School:

Devall: So, when other people talk with you about this, you know about the fact you’re making history or any of that, what do you say back to them? Or do you just not pay it any mind?

Hardy (C): I mean it’s just something that we’ve heard a lot before, so we just say the same thing every time like oh, we’re honored to be the last … yeah, we’re gonna miss it. That’s all I can really say about it.

Trotter (E): Yeah, it’s a lot of talk, but it don’t really come from us, it’s from parents and others

Devall: So, what would you say back to them? Maybe that thing you kind of wish you said, but afraid –

Trotter (E): That’s what I want to tell a lot of people. Can you stop talking about it ‘cause you really are getting on my nerves. I mean at a certain point of time you hear it so much, and sometimes it be coming from the same people or the same group of people. You already know how we feel so why do you keep asking us the same question?  …  Go to the board, go to the judge, go to the people like that. You already know how we feel. We don’t want it to happen, but we’ve accepted it, and we’re moving on.

Hardy (C): Yeah, like she said we always get asked about the past like over and over again and nobody ever asked us about the future.

Richards (E): I know at the barbershop, they ask me about the football team a lot. They think it’s going to be a lot of conflict, but really it ain’t. Everybody that played for Cleveland High kind of stay in the same neighborhood as East Side, and wherever we lacked at, in that particular position, then we kind of gained when we joined together. So, it’ll be a better football team overall. It really won’t be no conflict. It was like  a rivalry thing ‘cause it’s tradition, but it don’t too much matter now.

Devall:  When you say the same people are asking about it, what do you mean?

Aallyah Wright, Mississippi Today

East Side High graduating seniors (from left) Jakobe Richards, Jakiya Watson and J’Terrica Trotter participate in the Reveal conversation about Cleveland public schools.

Trotter (E): It’s mostly coming from people who don’t have children in the school district or people that it won’t even affect. They’re always asking us how we feel about it and what they think when really their opinion doesn’t matter ‘cause they won’t be affected by it anyway it goes.

Hardy (C): I think one reason that’s kind of annoying is like that’s the reason it’s happening is because people who it has no impact on, no effect on, they’re the ones that came in and came and made us change … like people up in New Hampshire coming in and reporting all of this stuff, writing all that stuff on the internet, writing about how terrible we are when they’ve probably never set foot in Cleveland or Mississippi at at all.

Watson (E):  I feel like outsiders try to make it a race thing because like East Side … it’s 100 percent African-American except for one Mexican girl, and Cleveland High is majority white, and they have different –

Hardy (C): Actually, I think it’s 60, 40 — 60 (percent) African-American and 40 white (at Cleveland High).

Watson (E): Yeah, they try to make it like white school, black school when they fail to realize we interact with each other. We have vo-tech. We exchange classes. We have people that know each other, and they try to make it seem like, ‘Oh, well they’re white, we’re black, they don’t interact with each other so we need to combine them.” But in actuality we know one another. Even if we don’t know everyone, you still have that communication going on and people mingling with each other.

Trotter (E): Everyone in our district knows that we have a choice of where we want to go to school. It’s not because, “Oh, white people don’t want to go to East Side because they’re scared.” I mean you got a choice. You can go wherever you want to go. It’s not their fault they don’t want to come over here. And, it’s not our fault that some of us don’t want to go over there. Sometimes it ain’t even about that. It’s about situations you’re in. Some people can’t travel to the other side of town, so they have to go to East Side. Some people can’t travel to the other side of town, so they go to Cleveland High. People just look at stuff racially, like she said, instead of looking at circumstances.

Devall: But did any of you ever think about going to the other school?

Trotter (E): I went to the other school. I left Hayes Cooper, and I went to Margaret Green. And then, my mother was a Trojan. She graduated from East Side … I felt I had better opportunities at East Side than I did Cleveland High. I stayed closer to East Side, and now look at me. I’m the last Miss East Side, so I feel like that was the best choice I could have made personally for me.

Hardy (C):  A lot of it has to do with where your parents went to school. I know my dad and my grandfather and like two of my aunts and my uncle, they all went to Cleveland High, so like why would I go to East Side when my whole family went to Cleveland High School? And I think a lot of other people feel the same way, I’m sure.

Carmichael (C): I had family members who went to East Side and Cleveland High, so I just had the choice to go to either one. But my big thing on choosing a school I wanted to go to, I wanted more of a diverse group of people. I wanted to see other races, so I chose Cleveland High.

McLaughlin (C): My parents, the past two years, they haven’t tried to push anything on me, but they made it clear it was my choice to go wherever I wanted to go. We’re not from here, so my parents have very different views from a lot of people who have grown up living here. The majority of my friends are at Cleveland High, so I stayed there. I was already working to skip a grade, but I did take as many classes as I could at East Side.

Devall: Do you see or can you imagine what the schools are going to be like once they do get together?

Hardy (C): My little brother … he wouldn’t go to private school for the people, but as far as athletics go, I mean every kid wants to play a sport in high school. He’s not that big. He’s smaller than everyone else. He’s not gonna have much of a chance at a 5A school.

Watson (E): Some people will get looked over just because of how big the school will be. With East Side, you had the opportunity to shine just because it was a smaller school, and you were able to get looked at easier. But at a 5A school, you will have some people that outshine others and everyone won’t have an equal opportunity. Even in class, with a bigger class it’s harder to see everyone and give everyone the same attention that everyone needs.

Richards (E): I got two twin brothers, probably in the seventh or eighth grade, they would probably rather go to Cleveland High anyways than East Side because I would say they are a little weaker … With everybody coming together, it’ll make them tougher and have them ready for the real world.

Aallyah Wright, Mississippi Today

Participants engage in conversation via Skype over refreshments and food.

 

Coleman: What advice would you give to the school board on implementing certain ways or processes so that the new school year could go more at ease? Like activities for students or teachers?

Trotter (E): I would honestly say keep the kids first. Keep kids first. Don’t worry about what parents have to say.

Hardy (C): Talk to the kids. Ask the kids what they want.

Watson (E):  And it should be a vote on everything like it was for the school name and mascot. It should be –

Carmichael (C): Student-oriented.

Watson (E): You have parents that like to talk and vote on stuff, but they actually don’t have to go through with the decisions and change their ways because they just have to drop us off at school. Then, we don’t see them until we get home.

Devall: What should your parents know about where you are in relation to each other’s schools and in relation to what Cleveland could be? What do you think they ought to know about this moment that maybe you’ve been afraid to tell them?

McLaughlin (C): I tell my parents everything really. My dad grew up in California and my mom lived in Knoxville, Tenn. Their opinions, their beliefs, are very different from that of all of my friend’s parents. They’ve been for the consolidation the whole time we’ve lived here … They’ve even toured Bayou [Academy] and my sister is going there next year. I know it caused quite a bit of argument in our family for a while. I’m honored to be the last class, but if I were from here, it would probably mean more to me, but I’m glad it’s happening … My parents … it doesn’t affect them as much as it does a lot of Cleveland people that live here.

Aallyah Wright, Mississippi Today

(From left) Graduating Cleveland High School seniors Ja’Darrius Carmichael, Emma Hardy and Madeline McLauchlin discuss their feelings about the impending merger of the communitys high schools.

Hardy (C): I completely understand her viewpoint because I know if I didn’t have family from here I probably wouldn’t be as concerned about it. My dad, he hates to see Cleveland High School go because he was really involved in every way possible as were his parents. Coming from my parents, it’s sad because Cleveland High School isn’t going to be any longer.

Carmichael (C): My parents, neither one of them graduated from Cleveland High or East Side, so they’re kind of okay with it. They’re fine with the consolidation. They believe everyone should come together and be together at one same school. I think it’s going to be okay because I have a younger brother, and I think he’ll be fine growing up in a diverse environment.

Trotter (E): I would tell my parents I am who I am today because of my experiences on both sides of town. I’ve experienced being a Margaret Green Junior High Wildcat, an East Side High School Trojan, and I couldn’t have been a better person if it weren’t for both the experiences I’ve had.

Watson (E): Of course everyone is sad to see us losing our schools and traditions, but my mother feels that it’ll be beneficial to Cleveland as a whole, not just one separate group, but all benefit from the combining.

Richards (E): My parents kind of got the same viewpoint I got about it. We can learn something from each other instead of being so segregated. Be more diverse and open minded about things, and we could learn something from them and they could learn something from us. It’s just a better situation overall.

• • •

Reveal – a website, public radio program, podcast and social media platform – is where the Center for Investigative Reporting publishes its work. The mission is to engage and empower the public through investigative journalism and groundbreaking storytelling in order to spark action, improve lives and protect our democracy.

  • Sherry Shepard

    When we don’t know and appreciate our history, we are doomed to repeat it. This is a sad commentary, as I am moved to tears that so little appreciation is shown for the death, blood, sweat, and tears shed to afford blacks and other minorities the rights we now enjoy. Opinions are one thing and it is important to provide a forum for the opinions of others. But there are some topics that kids will understand the depth and breadth later on in life. THIS IS ONE OF THOSE TOPICS! I do not blame the kids, for they are being kids. But this is DEEPER, SO MUCH DEEPER THAN ANY SKYPE CONVERSATION WITH A BUNCH OF TEENAGERS CAN INFORM! It is evident that the statement made demonstrate no connection to the sacrifices of others to make today and the future better for not only these kids, but for generations to come. I am sadden by this gross exploitation of these kids’ lack of depth on this most sacred, sensitive, and serious topic! THIS IS A SAD COMMENTARY, AND I AM UTTERLY APPALLED!

  • Sherry Shepard

    I am still disturbed by this article and the exploitation of the ignorance (lack of knowledge — not meant to be insulting) of minors! THIS IS A 62-YEAR OLD RACIAL SEGREGATION AND DISCRIMINATION CASE, PURE AND COMPLICATED, WHERE SCHOOL OFFICIALS HAVE INTENTIONALLY, DELIBERATELY, AND PERSISTENTLY SOUGHT TO KEEP THESE SAME BLACK STUDENTS FEATURED IN THIS ARTICLE RELEGATED TO INFERIORITY AND LOW EXPECTATIONS. These students don’t have a clue as to how this case seeks to position them and the generations to come for success now and in the future.

    IT’S DEEPER THAN THIS SKYPE CONVERSATION CAN CAPTURE. ADD THE FACTS, THE DATA, THE COURT DISPOSITIONS SINCE 1965, THE WILL OF THE BOARD OVER THESE YEARS, THE DISTRICT’S ATTEMPTS TO CIRCUMVENT THE LAW AND EVERY PLAN TO DATE, THE SETUPS OF FAILURE, THE LIES, THE DECEPTIONS, THE LACK OF TRANSPARENCY, AND THE LACK OF PARENT/COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND USE THAT TO PREFACE THE QUESTIONS YOU POSED TO THE CHILDREN WITH THIS REAL DATA AND I BET THE STUDENTS’ ANSWERS WOULD HAVE BEEN DIFFERENT. Kids tend to think in the “here and now as it relates to ME”! That’s truth and the beauty of being kids! This is a seriously, deeply debilitating topic, and to deduce it to this uninformed attack on 62 years of racial oppression of CHILDREN is a low, low, deeply insensitive journalistic move.

    The questions posed by the adults in this project had no foundation, no historical significance, no FACT BASE. Y’all set these innocent kids up to sound stupid, and this is egregiously wrong!
    For kids to tell A SCHOOL BOARD WHO HAS BEEN PROVEN BY THE COURT TO “LACK THE WILL” TO DO WHAT IS BEST FOR ALL KIDS AND A SCHOOL BOARD WHO HAS BEEN PROVEN BY THE COURT TO HAVE “CAUSED HARM TO COUNTLESS GENERATIONS OF KIDS” ABOUT THEIR FUTURE IS SUICIDAL!
    THIS SCHOOL BOARD IS IN NO POSITION TO INFORM THE FUTURE OF “ANY CHILD IN THE CLEVELAND SCHOOL DISTRICT”! WHY WOULD YOU GIVE SATAN INPUT INTO A PLAN FOR THE IMPROVEMENT FOR ANGELS? SATAN DOES NOT HAVE THE BEST INTERESTS OF ANGELS AT HEART, AND NEITHER DOES THIS SCHOOL BOARD AS IT RELATES TO ALL KIDS IN THE CLEVELAND SCHOOL DISTRICT!
    One of the Mississippi Today / Delta Arts Alliance Questions was posed as follows, along with student responses where I did some redacting for the kids’ sake.

    Coleman:
    What advice would you give to the school board on implementing certain ways or
    processes so that the new school year could go more at ease? Like activities
    for students or teachers?

    Student Responses:
    I would honestly say keep the kids first. Keep kids first. Don’t worry
    about what parents have to say.

    Talk to the kids. Ask the kids what they want.

    And it should be a vote on everything like it was for the school
    name and mascot. It should be –

    Student-oriented.

    You have parents that like to talk and vote on stuff, but they actually
    don’t have to go through with the decisions and change their ways because they
    just have to drop us off at school. Then, we don’t see them until we get home.
    I AM APPALLED AT THE ADULTS INVOLVED IN THIS TRAVESTY OF JUSTICE AND PERSPECTIVE ABOUT SUCH A DEEPLY SENSITIVE, SERIOUS TOPIC. THESE KIDS HAVE BEEN EGREGIOUSLY EXPOITED!
    I understand how adult decisions affect kids in powerful and sensitive ways. Yet, kids lack the maturity of fully comprehend the full depth, breadth, and scope of adult decisions when they are children. Time proves that this comes to full revelation later for kids. When kids say things like “don’t worry about what parents have to say” to a School Board who has dangled “the apple of black oppression, death of kids hopes and dreams, inferiority, segregation, discrimination, and low expectations,” at them for 62 years is unfathomable.
    I am at a loss for words at these responses from the kids, but, most importantly at the lack of seriousness or thoughtfulness on the topic by Mississippi Today and the Delta Arts Alliance. YOU ARE WRONG, AND THIS IS NOT JOURNALISM — IT’S EXPLOITATION IN THE MOST EGREGIOUS SENSE OF OUR MOST VULNERABLE!
    THIS CASE INVOLVING 62 YEARS OF RACIAL OPPRESSION OF STUDENTS — NOT JUST THE PAST 90 DAYS OF FAKING ON THE PART OF THE CSD SCHOOL BOARD — HAS TO BE THE FOCUS ON EVERY FORUM! I DID NOT READ ANY HISTORICAL BASIS OR FOUNDATION FOR THE QUESTIONS, AND THE STUDENTS SHEDDED NO LIGHT AS TO WHETHER THEY KNEW.
    YOU CAN’T TALK ABOUT SOLUTIONS WITH A FRAMING THE PROBLEM. NO PROBLEM WAS ADEQUATELY FRAMED IN THIS CONVERSATION OR PREFACED THROUGH THE QUESTIONS.
    Parents have a perspective that children can’t see or understand as kids. Those are the joys of being “children”! I understand that kids will not agree with all of the decisions “I” as a parent must make on their behalf.
    But as a parent, I can’t bow in to what my child “wants” when I KNOW IT WILL HARM THEM! Kids get upset at their parents when the parent refuses to allow them to touch a HOT STOVE! I’ve had some of mine fall on the floor screaming and yelling at some of my no’s! But in the end, I had to hold firm because I knew the harm that my child could not see AS A CHILD! Those are the joys and heartaches of PARENTING. In the end, the kids will learn that their parents’ decisions and the advocacy of few can TRANSFORM A LOT FOR THE GOOD OF ALL! WE ARE DOING IT FOR YOUR GOOD, ALL KIDS’ GOOD, AND FOR OUR COMMUNITY’S GOOD!
    THIS HURTS DEEP! IT HURTS DEEP BECAUSE IT IS MUCH DEEPER THAN THIS ARTICLE!
    P.S. I MUST NOTE THAT I HAVE “NEVER” ASKED A CHILD “WHAT DID THEY THINK ABOUT THIS CASE” OR ANY ASPECT THEREOF! IT’S NOT A CHILD QUESTION IN MY OPINION! THIS IS A MATTER OF JUSTICE AND EQUALITY AND EQUITY FOR ALL BASED ON OUR RIGHTS AS AMERICANS, DEEP AND ULTIMATE SACRIFICES OF OUR FOREFATHERS, AND A WORLD FREE OF RACISM AND BIGOTRY! IT’S DEEPER!